Suggest You
#1 in Business Subscribe Email Print

You are here: Home > Business > Business > Fire Your Analyst (Part I)

Tags

  • analyzing
  • evidence
  • cultural
  • personal opinion
  • confident should
  • their opinion

  • Links

  • SEO Success: Step Three is Creating Long-Term Popularity
  • Payday Loans ??“ Failing to Pay, Pay the Price!
  • Buying Safely And With Confidence At Online Auction Sites
  • Suggest You - Fire Your Analyst (Part I)

    Cultural Sensitivity in Business
    Forget the saying ‘the world is getting smaller’ – it has gotten smaller. Advances in transport and communications technology combined with the development of a world economy have resulted in people from different nations, cultures, languages and backgrounds now communicating, meeting and doing business with one another more than ever.There are some observers that claim this new found intimacy has lead to a greater understanding of ‘the other’ and as a result our cultural differences are in fact diminishing. However, in reality the opposite is true. As we come together our cultural differences become accentuated as we start to realise that the rest o
    their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this st

    Making the Most of Business Trip Hotel Stays
    For many of you who are businessman and businesswomen, traveling becomes second nature. As you jump from city to city, it gets to the point where people ask you what you do for a living and you have to refrain from saying, “I’m a Nomad, what about you?” Traveling for business can certainly be a pain in the bags, but with a few simple changes, you may find the transition from home to away to be easier than assumed.There are several things you can do to improve a business trip. From taking a picture of your family and placing it on the hotel room desk to making sure you’ve packed a portable phone charger so that your cell phone will never be dead in ti
    A recent scientific study (Craigie M, Loader B, Burrows R, Muncer S. Reliability of Health Information on the Internet: An Examination of Experts' Ratings. Journal of Medical Internet Research. 2002 Jan-Mar;4(1):e2) measured how consistent are experts when analyzing qualitative data. The data included the text from 18 threads (series of connected messages) posted on a message board by individuals suffering from a chronic disease. Each thread consisted of a start message, or question, and a number of responses, or answers. The experts processing the data were five doctors who worked together in the same specialist unit, and who had at least five years experience in treating the chosen disease. To process the data, the doctors devised the following two scales. The start message or question was coded according to a 6-part scale: A = excellent; B = less good but with some details; C = poor with little detail; D = vague; E = misleading or irrelevant; F = incomprehensible. The responses or answers were coded according to another 6-part scale: A = evidence based, excellent; B = accepted wisdom; C = personal opinion; D = misleading, irrelevant; E = false; F = possibly dangerous.

    After processing the data, the codes assigned by all five experts were compared using three statistical tests: kappa, gamma, and Kendall's W. The results showed poor agreement between the codes of all five experts in both the starting question and the responses. Moreover, two of the five experts showed a statistical significant dis-agreement between the codes they assigned to the question, and different pairing of experts showed contradictions between the codes they assigned to the responses. In simple terms, when one doctor labeled an answer with A = evidence based, excellent, another doctor labeled the same answer with E = false, or even F = possibly dangerous.

    Points to consider:

    1. The first stage of most decisions is gathering data. For instance, prior to making a marketing decision, researchers conduct focus groups, perform in-depth interviews, or use open-ended questions in surveys to ask customers for their opinion. Before hiring a new employee, human resource managers conduct interviews with candidates to gather information about their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this st

    Company Registration In Australia - An Overview
    Company registration in the Australian market is regulated by government policies, and in order to keep within the guidelines, you'll need to be aware of what has to be done.According to ASIC (Australian Securities and Investments Commission), these are the steps they recommend to get you started:Step 1: Decide on your business structureYou need to find out if a company structure best suits your business needs. The best way to do this is to check with a lawyer or other professional body that is related to this area.Step 2: Choose a company nameA company name must indi
    octors who worked together in the same specialist unit, and who had at least five years experience in treating the chosen disease. To process the data, the doctors devised the following two scales. The start message or question was coded according to a 6-part scale: A = excellent; B = less good but with some details; C = poor with little detail; D = vague; E = misleading or irrelevant; F = incomprehensible. The responses or answers were coded according to another 6-part scale: A = evidence based, excellent; B = accepted wisdom; C = personal opinion; D = misleading, irrelevant; E = false; F = possibly dangerous.

    After processing the data, the codes assigned by all five experts were compared using three statistical tests: kappa, gamma, and Kendall's W. The results showed poor agreement between the codes of all five experts in both the starting question and the responses. Moreover, two of the five experts showed a statistical significant dis-agreement between the codes they assigned to the question, and different pairing of experts showed contradictions between the codes they assigned to the responses. In simple terms, when one doctor labeled an answer with A = evidence based, excellent, another doctor labeled the same answer with E = false, or even F = possibly dangerous.

    Points to consider:

    1. The first stage of most decisions is gathering data. For instance, prior to making a marketing decision, researchers conduct focus groups, perform in-depth interviews, or use open-ended questions in surveys to ask customers for their opinion. Before hiring a new employee, human resource managers conduct interviews with candidates to gather information about their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this st

    How To Start An Internet Business From Home
    WORKING FROM HOME SUCCESSFULLY SOUNDS GREAT, BUT WHERE DO I START - AND HOW?Initially it is important to realize the pitfalls of working from home on the internet. Here are those that are the most common:SCAMS There are thousands of dishonest people on the internet who are eager to scam you out of your hard earned money without another thought. BEWARELACK OF MOTIVATION This is a common problem because most people are used to dealing with a boss who has expectations of what he wants of you. This of course and the fear of being fired is sufficient motivation for you. However working from home for yourself on the internet is a whol
    irrelevant; E = false; F = possibly dangerous.

    After processing the data, the codes assigned by all five experts were compared using three statistical tests: kappa, gamma, and Kendall's W. The results showed poor agreement between the codes of all five experts in both the starting question and the responses. Moreover, two of the five experts showed a statistical significant dis-agreement between the codes they assigned to the question, and different pairing of experts showed contradictions between the codes they assigned to the responses. In simple terms, when one doctor labeled an answer with A = evidence based, excellent, another doctor labeled the same answer with E = false, or even F = possibly dangerous.

    Points to consider:

    1. The first stage of most decisions is gathering data. For instance, prior to making a marketing decision, researchers conduct focus groups, perform in-depth interviews, or use open-ended questions in surveys to ask customers for their opinion. Before hiring a new employee, human resource managers conduct interviews with candidates to gather information about their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this st

    Packaging Tape
    Packaging tape is a very important and useful item in the entire process of packaging items. There are many different kinds of packaging tape which are available for use by the customers.Carton sealing tape is used to seal large cardboard cartons. Colored carton sealing tape is often considered to be ideal for identifying inventories, sorting shipments and dating the products. Filament tape is considered to be ideal for bundling tubes, sealing cartons, palletizing, unitizing and repairing. The fiberglass strands give the filament tape tear resistance as well as extra strength for holding heavy loads and packages. The different kinds of filament tape
    . In simple terms, when one doctor labeled an answer with A = evidence based, excellent, another doctor labeled the same answer with E = false, or even F = possibly dangerous.

    Points to consider:

    1. The first stage of most decisions is gathering data. For instance, prior to making a marketing decision, researchers conduct focus groups, perform in-depth interviews, or use open-ended questions in surveys to ask customers for their opinion. Before hiring a new employee, human resource managers conduct interviews with candidates to gather information about their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this st

    Fundraising Business Helps Non-Profits Hit Funding Goals
    One of the more popular ways some charities use to raise money is through the contracting with a fundraising business, to gather donations in their name. Some may argue that the use of such as business is a distraction to the individual charity, however the results have encourage others to shift their efforts on their service to the public and leave the fundraising business to the professional fundraisers.In the usual realm of fundraising, volunteers from within the organization talk to the public by any means possible to secure donations for their charity. The times spent seeking donations is done either during or outside the time they spend working
    their background and proficiencies. Before making an investment, investors collect articles, press releases, and reports about their target companies. In all these cases, and many others, the data is presented in the form of words. In light of this study, how confident should you be in the "professional" analysis of these words?

    2. How worried should you be when a market researcher is presenting the analysis of focus groups, in-depth interviews, or answers to open-ended questions in a survey? A typical focus group holds about 12,000 words. The data in this study included 18 threads. An average thread consists of about 5 postings with about 120 words each. These numbers suggest that the data in this study included 10,800 words; less than a single focus group. In contrast, a typical market research study consists of 4-8 focus groups, or 4 to 8 times more text. So, if the experts in this study failed to show consistency with a volume of data equivalent to a single focus group, what are the chances that a market researcher will show consistency with a much larger dataset?

    3. In this study, the analysts were doctors with at least five years of experience in treating the specific chronic disease. These analysts possess a much higher level of expertise in the research subject relative to even the most experienced moderators and interviewers analyzing qualitative customer data, the most experienced human resource managers analyzing candidate data, or the most schooled investment analyst. So, if these highly trained experts failed to show consistent processing of qualitative data, what are the chances that the less trained professionals (and layman) will show consistent analysis of their data?

    4. The criterion in this study was whether an answer is "evidence based" (see code A) or not. This is an objective criterion. Unlike this study, the great majority of qualitative studies involve subjective criteria such as tastes, morals, values, or preferences. If the doctors failed to consistently apply a single objective criterion when coding the text, how can the less trained professionals (and layman) be trusted to consistently apply a large set of subjective criteria when evaluating qualitative data?

    5. In this study pairs of doctors assigned different codes to the same question or answer. For instance, one doctor labeled an answer with A = evidence based, excellent; while another doctor labeled the same answer with E = false, or even F = possibly dangerous. Who is right? After all this is medicine and both cannot be right. Who should you believe? And what should you do as decision maker? If you believe that the first doctor is right, you should regard the response as great advice and follow its directives. If you believe that the second doctor is right, you should run for you life. Now, if suc

    HTTP = HTML link (for blogs, profiles,phorums):
    <a href="http://www.suggestyou.com/article/3782/suggestyou-Fire-Your-Analyst-Part-I.html">Fire Your Analyst (Part I)</a>

    BB link (for phorums):
    [url=http://www.suggestyou.com/article/3782/suggestyou-Fire-Your-Analyst-Part-I.html]Fire Your Analyst (Part I)[/url]

    Related Articles:

    Finding the Right Office Space for Your Business

    Localization Of Products

    Your Brand Makes People Feel Something

    Bookmark it: del.icio.us digg.com reddit.com netvouz.com google.com yahoo.com technorati.com furl.net bloglines.com socialdust.com ma.gnolia.com newsvine.com slashdot.org simpy.com shadows.com blinklist.com